SCHOOL BOARD OF PINELLAS COUNTY, FLORIDA

 

REGULAR MEETING OCTOBER 8, 2002

 

        The School Board of Pinellas County, Florida, met in Regular Session on Tuesday, October 8, 2002, at 1:00 P.M. in the Conference Hall of the Administration Building, 301 4th Street SW, Largo, Florida.  Present: Mr. Lee Benjamin, Chairman; Mrs. Nancy N. Bostock, Vice Chairman; Mrs. Carol J. Cook, Mrs. E. Jane Gallucci, Dr. Max R. Gessner, Mrs. Linda S. Lerner, and Ms. Janice Starling, Members; Dr. J. Howard Hinesley, Superintendent and Ex-officio Secretary to the Board; Dr. John Stewart, Deputy Superintendent; Mr. Lanse Johansen, Chief Business Officer; and, Mr. John Bowen, School Board Attorney.

 

        The Invocation was given by, Pastor M. J. Glymph, Prince of Peace Lutheran Church, Largo FL.  This was followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.

 

        Introduction of the following representatives of professional and community organizations was given by Dr. Ron Stone, Associate Superintendent for Human Resources and Public Affairs: Carolyn Smith, PESPA; Lindsey Walker and Jacintha Anderson, Students Rights & Responsibilities Committee, Seminole High School; Bill Williamson, Operations Team; and, Kelly Ryan Gilmer, The St. Petersburg Times.

 

        Mr. Benjamin introduced Erica Tabor, a Senior at Osceola High School, and a student intern in the Executive Internship Program in the Television Production Department.

 

        It was moved by Dr. Gessner and seconded by Mrs. Cook to adopt the agenda.  

 

 

ADD:                  ATTORNEY’S REPORT – Request approval to retain Thomas M. Gonzalez of the firm Thompson, Sizemore & Gonzalez to represent the School Board in the case of Graham v. Pinellas County School Board, Case No. 8:02-cv-1157-T-17MSS

 

           PULL:                 CONSENT #3, #5, and #8

 

        The motion to adopt the agenda was carried with a 7-0 vote.

 

A.      Mr. Jim Madden, Director, Unitary Status Implementation, presented the Choice Update. 

 

B.      Lindsey Walker and Jacintha Anderson, Students Rights and Responsibilities Committee, Seminole High School, shared information regarding activities at their school.

 

C.      Dr. Hinesley presented Dr. Bill Heller, University of South Florida, for recognition by the Board.  Dr. Heller thanked the Board for this recognition and for what they do for children.

 

Dr. Heller was greeted by the Board and presented with a globe trophy in appreciation for “making a world of difference” in the field of education.

 

D.      Mr. Elliott Stern of Raymond James, and Ms. Valerie White, Principal of Mount Vernon Elementary School, presented a report on the partnership between Raymond James & Associates, Inc. and Mount Vernon Elementary School. 

 

          Mr. Stern and Ms. White were greeted by the Board.

 

E.      Ms. Pam Harshbarger, Director for Exceptional Student Education, stated that the Governor and his Cabinet have declared the week of October 6-12, 2002, as Exceptional Student Education Week.  Ms. Harshbarger presented a resolution from the Governor recognizing the dedication of all exceptional student staff and teachers. 

 

Ms. Harshbarger introduced the following individuals who recently received special recognitions:

 

                Margaret (Pam) Bryant

                    Council for Exceptional Children Suncoast 176 ESE

                    Teacher of the Year

 

                    Susan Johnson

                    Council for Exceptional Children Suncoast 176 ESE

                    Jack R. Lamb Rookie of the Year Award

 

                    Susan Daniels

                    Council for Exceptional Children Suncoast 176

                    Nancy Givens Administrator of the Year Award

 

Ms. Bryant, Ms. Johnson, and Ms. Daniels were greeted and congratulated by the Board Members.

 

F.      Ms. Carolyn Underwood, Pinellas County Teachers Association, addressed the Board regarding the paperwork required for completion by ESE (exceptional student education) teachers.  Ms. Underwood presented a handout to the Board Members with background information and requested that the Board do what they can to ease the load for these teachers.  Ms. Underwood encouraged the Board Members to visit ESE teachers to see first hand the amount of paperwork associated with their job. 

 

          Discussion followed by Board members.  Mrs. Cook suggested that Ms. Underwood supply the Board Office with a list of teachers who would welcome a visit from a Board Member.  Mrs. Lerner suggested that any practice by a teacher to handle the paperwork be placed on a “best practice” site on Places.

 

1.      Dr. Hinesley stated that Ms. Bolivia Walker, Food Service Manager, Bay Vista Elementary School, had agreed to withdraw her request for an administrative hearing and be terminated from her employment with the district.   Dr. Hinesley requested that the Board, therefore, dismiss Ms. Walker.

 

1a.    It was moved by Mrs. Gallucci, seconded by Mrs. Cook, and carried with a 7-0 vote to dismiss Ms. Bolivia Walker, Food Service Manger, Bay Vista Elementary School, effective October 8, 2002.

 

2.      It was moved by Dr. Gessner, seconded by Mrs. Gallucci, and carried with a 7-0 vote to approve the consent agenda, as amended.

 

2a.    To approve the minutes of the Regular School Board Meeting of September 24, 2002, as submitted.

 

2b.    Mrs. Lerner, having pulled this item, suggested that the Proposed Superintendent’s Improvement Plan be tabled to allow discussion of the details of the plan at the next Board workshop.

 

It was moved by Mrs. Bostock and seconded by Dr. Gessner  to approve the Proposed Superintendent’s Improvement Plan.

 

It was moved by Mrs. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Gallucci, and carried with a 7-0 vote, to table the motion to approve the Proposed Superintendent’s Improvement Plan to allow discussion of the details for the plan at the next workshop.

 

2c.    To approve the Personnel Actions as Recommended by the Superintendent.  (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

2d.    This item was pulled to allow a speaker from the audience.

 

It was moved by Mrs. Cook and seconded by Dr. Gessner to approve the 403 (b) Tax Deferred Annuity and 457 (b) Deferred Compensation Programs Guidelines.

 

Tom Moriarty, InterSecurities/AEGON – Addressed the Board to request that other criteria be included in the guidelines  considered when staff is selecting the providers for 403(b) and 457(b) programs.  Mr. Moriarty requested that a company’s partnership with schools, i.e., mentoring and financial support of the Doorways Scholarship Program, be considered; that oral presentations from providers be considered to further clarify their services to the district; and, that certification of vendors be requested.

 

Discussion followed by Dr. Hinesley, Mr. Bowen, Board Members, and Mr. Ted Pafundi (Director of Risk Management and Insurance).

 

Dr. Hinesley expressed concern with the legality of Mr. Moriarty’s first request and suggested that the Board allow him to research the possibilities of the second and third requests.

 

Mr. Pafundi clarified that these are just guidelines.  He also informed the Board that he is working on forming an appeal process for vendors who are not selected.

 

The motion was carried with a 7-0 vote  to approve the 403 (b) Tax Deferred Annuity and 457 (b) Deferred Compensation Programs Guidelines.

 

2e.    To approve the Following Special Project:  (Copy/copies, as appropriate, to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

          -    Prevention and Early Intervention Project:  $968,900

 

2f.     To approve the Financial Statements for the Month Ending July 31, 2002 for Fiscal Year 2002-03.

 

2g.    It was moved by Mrs. Gallucci and seconded by Dr. Gessner to  approve the First Amendment to Charter Contract with Academie Da Vinci, Inc.

 

          Mrs. Gallucci, having pulled this item, stated that Mr. Tom Wittmer, Assistant School Board Attorney, has done an excellent job communicating the purpose of these additional clauses to the Academie.   Mrs. Gallucci stated that one question that still needs to be answered is whether these clauses should be sunsetted for Academie Da Vinci, Inc., in 2007.

 

          Mr. Wittmer addressed the Board to state that he has spoken with Rick Escarraz, Esq., (Attorney for the NAACP Legal Defense Fund) and that the following has been added in paragraph 5, “That these new sections of the charter shall remain in effect until such time that the sponsor implements choice plan without ratio.” 

 

          Mrs. Gallucci clarified that “sponsor” refers to the district and questioned whether this additional phrase is acceptable to the Academie.  The principal of Academie Da Vinci, present at this meeting, indicated her approval.

 

          The motion was carried with a 7-0 vote to approve the First Amendment to Charter Contract with Academie Da Vinci, Inc.  (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

2h.    To approve the Agreement Between Big Brothers Big Sisters of Pinellas County and the School Board of Pinellas County for Rawlings, Lakewood, and Rio Vista elementary schools. (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

2i.      To approve the Supplemental Survey for Dunedin Highland Middle School (0031).

 

2j.      To approve the Supplemental Survey for Oak Grove Middle School (0072).

 

2k.     To approve the Supplemental Survey for Safety Harbor Middle School (0097).

 

2l.      To approve the Supplemental Survey for Shore Acres Elementary School (0108).

 

2m.   To approve the Supplemental Survey for Sunset Hills Elementary School (0116).

 

2n.    To approve the Renewal Agreements for Dropout Prevention Programs at Department of Juvenile Justice and Community Agency Facilities. (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)       

 

2o.    To approve the Record Plat for the Campbell Park Elementary School, Douglas L. Jamerson, Jr. Elementary School, Fairmount Park Elementary School, Thurgood Marshall Middle School, James B. Sanderlin Elementary School, and Bay Point Elementary/Middle Schools; and Gulfport Elementary School.

 

2p.    To approve the Acceptance of Partial Substantial Completion of Construction of Bay Point Middle School as of August 6, 2002 (Food Service). (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

2q.    To approve the Acceptance of Partial Substantial Completion for Renovations and Additions to Maximo Elementary School as of July 15, 2002 (Phase I). (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

2r.     To approve the Acceptance of Partial Substantial Completion for new Construction of Meadowlawn Middle School as of July 22, 2002 (Phase I). (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

2s.    To approve the Agreement With Plisko Architecture, P.A., AIA for Architectural and Construction Contract Administration Services in Connection With new Construction for the Window and Cabinet Replacement Project at Bear Creek Elementary School in the Amount of $33,675. (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

2t.     To approve the Agreement With Robert P. Resch III Architect, for Architectural and Construction Contract Administration Services in Connection With Providing Cabinet Replacement at Sawgrass Lake Elementary School in the Amount of $29,760. (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

2u.    To approve Change Order No. 1 for the CCTV Installation Project at Meadowlawn Middle School.  This Change Order will increase the contract amount by $20,969 with an eight (8) day time extension. (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

2v.     To approve Change Order No. 11 for the Re-roofing and Exterior Renovations at Tarpon Springs Middle School.  This Change Order will increase the contract amount by $31,953 with no time extension. (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

2w.    To approve the Bids to Vendors at Prices in Bid Documents in Accordance with Bid Policies and Statutes. (Copy to be found in Supplemental Minute Book #98.)

 

3.      Dr. Hinesley’s report included the following:

 

Ø     Stated that he has been contacted by one of our partners in the public sector interested in knowing whether Dr. Hinesley personally, or he and the School Board, might be interested in partnering with SPC, USF, and others to join a position of why the constitutional amendment on class size has a negative impact. Discussion followed by Board Members and Dr. Hinesley.  It was moved by Dr. Gessner, seconded by Ms. Starling, and carried with a 7-0 vote to authorize the Superintendent to not only attend meetings of this group but to also represent this board’s opposition to the amendment based on today’s discussion and comments previously made by this board; and, that Dr. Hinesley should report back to the Board on the total membership of this group before adding the name of the Pinellas County School Board to the list supporting this effort.

 

Ø     Stated that the article recently printed in The St. Petersburg Times refers to a recommendation for “Places” that he received from Judy Ambler and with which he was in agreement.  Dr. Hinesley presented an example of an e-mail posted on “Places” which he felt was not appropriate for a district e-mail system to convey.

 

4.      Mr. Bowen’s report included the following:

 

Ø     Requested authority from the Board to retain Thomas M. Gonzalez of the firm of Thompson, Sizemore & Gonzalez to represent the School Board in the case of Graham v. Pinellas County School Board, Case No. 8:02-cv-1157-T-17MSS.  It was moved by Dr. Gessner, seconded by Mrs. Gallucci, and carried with a 7-0 vote to approve Mr. Bowen’s request.

 

5.      Reports from School Board Members were as follows:

 

          Schools Visited or Functions Attended by Board Members

 

          Meeting with St. Petersburg City Council and Mayor; DMAC meeting; Mentor Training Workshop at Southern Oak Elementary Mentor (Mrs. Cook – taught); Education Foundation Luncheon with Business Leaders; Education Foundation Presidents as Principals Luncheon.

 

          Concerns Expressed, Written, or Oral

 

          Mrs. Cook – Requested that Dr. Hinesley consider returning the publication, Topics to circulation in departments and schools as an informational tool to employees.  Dr. Hinesley agreed to consider this.

 

          Dr. Gessner – Stated that he had received a call regarding the closed-circuit televisions at Northeast High School and requested an update on the installation of those cameras.  Dr. Hinesley stated that he will check on this and report back to the Board.  Stated that the district had to reduce summer school due to financial issues and questioned whether the district could offer a fee-based opportunity for students repeating courses.  Dr. Hinesley stated that a fee can’t be charged for students who are making up a course, but that the district does charge for those students wishing to take a course for “enhancement” purposes.  Requested a copy of the form parents must complete to “opt out” their child from a class assignment.  Dr. Hinesley will forward that form to the Board Members.

 

          Mrs. Lerner – Questioned the proposed timeframe for the October 15 workshop, stating that she has a 5:30 p.m. commitment.  Mrs. Lerner questioned whether the agenda requires an earlier beginning.  Dr. Hinesley stated that the agenda calls for the workshop to be completed no later than 5:00 p.m.  Complimented the recent letter to the Editor by Rick Escarraz, Esq., written to explain the rationale and need for the complex Choice Plan.

 

          Mrs. Gallucci – Stated that the Board is invited to the unveiling of the extended learning adventure resulting from the partnership between the district and the County.  This unveiling will take place on October 30 at Stavros Institute.  Further details will be forwarded to the Board.  Complimented a recent article in Florida Trend regarding the state’s budget and revenue shortfalls.  Stated Judy Conte, President of FSBA, urged each member of the executive board to make an effort to inform the public of the contents in Article 9, Section 1 of the Florida Constitution which states that “the education of children is a fundamental value of the people of Florida and, therefore, a paramount duty of the state to make adequate provisions for the education of all children residing in these borders….”   Mrs. Gallucci proceeded to read Article 9.

 

6.      The meeting recessed at 3:36 p.m. and reconvened at 4:02 p.m.

 

7.      Dr. Hinesley presented for approval by the Board the request to set a Public Hearing and Authorize the Advertisement of the Public Hearing to Consider the Amendment to Policy 5.15 Reporting Student Progress and Class Ranking High School.  Dr. Hinesley stated that this is the first reading and that the second reading is scheduled for the November 12 meeting.  Dr. Hinesley stated that he had to look at what would have the least implication and, based on that, he was not recommending that the quality points be given retroactively.

 

7a.    It was moved by Dr. Gessner and seconded by Mrs. Cook to set a Public Hearing and Authorize the Advertisement of the Public Hearing to Consider the Amendment to Policy 5.15 Reporting Student Progress and Class Ranking High School.

 

          Matt Alderman (student- East Lake High), Meredith Johnson (student – East Lake High), Denise Prior (parent), Claire Walker (parent), Tara Brandenburger (student – Dunedin High), Scott Kinsler (Gibbs SAC chair), and Charles Fonshell (Dunedin High SAC chair) – Addressed the Board to request that the Board award quality points retroactively.

 

          Discussion followed by Board Members, Dr. Hinesley, Dr. John Stewart, and Mr. Tom Wittmer (Assistant School Board Attorney).

 

7b.    It was moved by Mrs. Gallucci, seconded by Ms. Starling, and carried with a 7-0 vote to amend the original motion and to direct the Superintendent to include all three options in the advertisement for this policy amendment.

 

7c.    The original motion to approve to Set a Public Hearing and Authorize the Advertisement of the Public Hearing to Consider the Amendment to Policy 5.15 Reporting Student Progress and Class Ranking High School, was carried with a 7-0 vote, as amended.

 

8.      Mrs. Cook stated that prior to the recess, she mentioned that PCCPTA had taken a stand on the Class Size Amendment but this is not correct.  Mrs. Cook stated, however, that PCCPTA is providing a forum regarding the Single Member District issue for the School Board on October 23, 2002, 7:00 p.m., at Stavros Institute.

 

9.      There being no further business to be brought before the Board, this meeting adjourned at 5:22 p.m.

 

 

                   ______________________       _____________________

                        Chairman                                     Secretary

 

/db(02Oct08)